Ten Biggest Hiring Mistakes
Prior to publishing our book, “You’re NOT The Person I Hired” we conducted an in-depth study of hiring practices in 134 different companies in the manufacturing, high-tech, distribution, retail
and service industries. The study examined 225 executive-level hires to
determine what worked well, what didn’t work well, and where most
companies tend to stumble.
Among its many findings, the study identified ten common hiring mistakes
that plague companies of all sizes. You can get the complete survey for free by clicking here
Three Causal Factors contributed greatly to the root cause of these mistakes:
In most cases, the finding suggested these hiring mistakes are not
caused by willful ignorance or negligence. Rather, hires that fail to
produce the desired results are most often the result of a predictable
combination of causal factors, including:
1) Inadequate preparation. The company fails to take the time to
outline a detailed, measurable definition of “success” that can
be used to source, evaluate and select candidates. Instead,
most hiring organizations rely on outdated or insufficient job
specs that merely list desired attributes, educational attainment
and other minimally useful criteria.
2) Lack of information. Many hiring managers lack the information
and training to hire effectively at the executive level.
3) Human nature. Interpersonal situations like interviews are often
guided primarily by gut feelings. The hiring team that has not
been trained to minimize these distractions is easily influenced
by preconscious perceptions and nonverbal cues.
In most cases it’s a lack of replicable hiring process to improve outcomes.
An Methodology for Success
The solution.
All that’s required is a structured approach that enables companies to
avoid the predictable pitfalls that plague many high-level hires. Based
on our experience hiring thousands of executives, we have developed a
methodology that consists of eight distinct steps:
1. Build a multi-faceted Success Factor Snapshot to guide the entire
search process.
2. Implement a deep sourcing strategy to reach and attract selective
and sleeper candidates.
3. Identify and verify success prospects.
4. Create structured dossiers on selected candidates to enable objective,
unbiased evaluation and comparison.
5. Conduct Success Factor-based panel interviews using a
“magnifying glass” probe methodology.
6. Proactively address and overcome obstacles to hire throughout the
entire active interviewing process.
7. Streamline compensation and benefit negotiations through structured
interview-based preliminary groundwork.
8. Follow through on the hire with proven transition communication
and work style assessment, coaching and facilitation.
Together, these steps comprise the “Success Factor Methodology,” (the content for our book, and our on-site hiring course ), a proven process for improving your ability to find, recruit and hire toplevel
executive talent. Each step in the process requires the full collaboration
of stakeholders in all the business units affected by the potential
hire. But when you employ the methodology in a consistent and systematic
manner, the outcome is a hire with a significantly increased
likelihood of long-term success.
For more information on building a successful hiring process visit our website at www.impacthiringsolutions.com
If you found this helpful please share with others. Also, please leave a comment to let us know if we are helping. Even, thanks, helpful, interesting or a short note is appreciated.




